ETF vs index fund: what's the difference?

By · · 5 min read · How we write our guides

"ETF vs index fund" compares two different kinds of thing. An index fund is a strategy: the fund holds what's in an index, like the S&P 500, instead of having a manager pick stocks. An ETF (exchange-traded fund) is a wrapper: a fund whose shares trade on a stock exchange during the day, like a stock. So many ETFs are index funds, and many index funds are mutual funds instead. The real question is usually "index ETF or index mutual fund?", and the answer comes down to how you buy, what minimum applies and what each one charges.

What an index fund is

An index is a list of companies chosen by set rules. The S&P 500, for example, holds about 500 large US companies; in Canada, the S&P/TSX Composite is the headline index. An index fund simply holds that list, so it moves with its index, minus a small yearly fee.

There's no team researching and picking stocks, which is a big part of why index funds tend to cost less than actively managed funds. Here's what that means in dollars, using made-up fees: a fund charging 0.05% a year costs $5 on every $10,000, while one charging 1.5% costs $150. That gap repeats every year, and money paid in fees stops growing for you.

One thing an index fund doesn't do is protect you from a falling market. When its index drops 20%, the fund drops about 20% too, plus its fee.

What an ETF is

An ETF is a fund you buy and sell through a brokerage account, at the market price, any time the exchange is open. A mutual fund works differently: you buy from the fund company (or through a brokerage), and every order received before the daily cutoff gets the same price, the fund's net asset value (NAV), worked out once a day after the market closes.

Because an ETF trades like a stock, its market price can sit a little above or below the value of what it holds, and you pay the gap between the buying and selling price (the bid-ask spread) when you trade. For a large, busy index ETF, that gap is usually small.

Most ETFs track an index, but not all. Some are actively managed, and some, such as leveraged or inverse ETFs, are built for narrow, short-term strategies and behave very differently from a broad index fund.

Index ETF vs index mutual fund side by side

Index ETFIndex mutual fund
What it holdsThe indexThe index
How you buyOn an exchange, through a brokerageFrom the fund company or through a brokerage
PriceChanges through the dayOnce a day, after the close (NAV)
MinimumUsually one share, or less where fractional shares are offeredSet by the fund; some ask for a minimum first purchase
Trading costsPossible commission, plus the bid-ask spreadPossible sales load or transaction fee, depending on fund and brokerage
Yearly feeExpense ratioExpense ratio, which can include a 12b-1 fee

If both track the same index, what they hold is the same. The trade-off is in the wrapper: an ETF is flexible to trade and usually has no minimum beyond one share, while a mutual fund keeps things simple with one price a day.

Fees: what to compare

The fee that matters most over the long term is the expense ratio: the yearly cost of running the fund, as a percentage of what you hold, taken out of the fund's assets. You never get a bill for it, which makes it easy to miss.

For a mutual fund, also check for a sales load (a charge when you buy or sell) and a 12b-1 fee (a yearly marketing and distribution charge, included in the expense ratio). For an ETF, check whether your brokerage charges a commission and how wide the bid-ask spread usually is.

How to check your own account: every US fund lists its fees in its prospectus, and FINRA's free Fund Analyzer lets you compare funds' costs side by side.

In Canada

The same split applies. Canadian investors can buy index ETFs on the TSX through a brokerage, or index mutual funds from a bank, a fund company or a dealer. Canada uses MER (management expense ratio) for the yearly fee, and every fund has a short summary document, Fund Facts for mutual funds and ETF Facts for ETFs, that shows it.

Since June 1, 2022, Canadian securities regulators have banned deferred sales charges on mutual funds (the fee once charged for selling within a few years of buying). Ongoing costs, such as trailing commissions paid to the dealer, are included in the MER.

Why index funds are a common starting point

Cost is a big part of the story. S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes SPIVA scorecards, which line up actively managed funds against the indexes they're measured by, for the US and for Canada. Over long stretches, the majority of active funds have historically fallen behind their index once fees are counted. A manager can come out ahead for a few years, but spotting which ones will do it ahead of time has proven difficult.

That's a reason index funds, in either wrapper, are so widely used for long-term investing. Which wrapper fits is a practical question about where you invest, how you like to buy, and what each fund costs. It's your call to make.

This is general information, not investment advice.

Learn it in a few minutes

The Bywell course covers this in "Index funds, and why they're most people's starting point," in the unit on the basics. For how a basket of stocks compares with owning single companies, see ETF vs individual stocks, and if you're choosing an account to hold your funds in, start with 401(k) vs Roth IRA.

Try this lesson free

Index funds, and why they're most people's starting point

6 min · The basics

Right here in your browser, no download. Read it in a few minutes, then answer questions that explain why each answer is right. Free includes the Start here unit, then 3 lessons a day.

Already investing? Follow your stocks and ask Claude or ChatGPT.

Common questions

Is an ETF an index fund?
Often, but not always. Most ETFs track an index, so they're index funds too. Some ETFs are actively managed or built for narrow, short-term strategies. And many index funds aren't ETFs at all: they're mutual funds.
Is an S&P 500 index fund the same as an S&P 500 ETF?
They hold the same list of about 500 large US companies, so their results tend to be close. The differences are in the wrapper: how you buy and sell, the minimum to get started, and the yearly fee each one charges.
Which usually costs less, an index ETF or an index mutual fund?
It depends on the fund, not the type. Both can charge very low yearly fees. Compare the expense ratio (MER in Canada), any sales load or 12b-1 fee on a mutual fund, and any trading commission and bid-ask spread on an ETF.
Can I hold either one in an IRA, a 401(k) or a TFSA?
Usually, yes. An IRA, TFSA or RRSP at a brokerage can generally hold both. A 401(k) offers only the funds on its plan's menu, which are often mutual funds or similar pooled funds. The account sets the tax rules; the fund is what's inside it.

Sources

  1. SEC Investor.gov: Mutual Funds and Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs)
  2. SEC Investor.gov: 12b-1 fees (glossary)
  3. FINRA: Fund Analyzer (compare fund fees and expenses)
  4. S&P Dow Jones Indices: SPIVA scorecards (U.S. and Canada)
  5. S&P Dow Jones Indices: S&P 500
  6. Canadian Securities Administrators: ban on deferred sales charges for mutual funds, in force June 1, 2022 (Jan 20, 2022)
  7. Ontario Securities Commission, GetSmarterAboutMoney: Mutual funds, Fund Facts and ETF Facts

General information and education, not investment advice. Bywell never makes buy, sell or hold recommendations.

Keep reading